"The tragedy, the true catastrophe, is that humanity continues”

I just don't know what exactly is good or bad. Initially I'm repulsed by the very idea of a movie version of a tragic event. I have a problem even looking at the cover of the movie. I see that plane everywhere. Everytime a plane flies too low, my eyes are trained on it. I work near Logan airport and I see hundreds of planes a week, yet I still have anxiety when I see "that plane." It's that plane that flies a little too low and flies at a slight angle. I saw a plane that looked just like it on I-90 going towards Boston, it looked like it was heading right for the Prudential building. My heart skipped a beat and my car slowed down. For that reason and many more I don't need to see this movie.
Why was this movie even made is the question that I really had. When I went to see "V for Vendetta" I saw the preview for "United 93" for the first time. I was disgusted. I really don't see a reason for a movie based on those events to be made on a for profit basis. I could tolerate and encourage a documentary for TV to be made. Why a theatrical movie. Why would you want to disrupt memories of the those events with a pantomime performance that is based on scattered audio and cell phone transcripts.
I think it's an egregious exploitation of people's emotions on a very tragic event. The fact is that people will be getting overwhelmed watching this movie. It isn't because it was a well written script that happened to play ones heartstrings so effectly that it produced emotion. The fact that the movie is based on real events that we all saw play out on television and internet news websites is what makes this movie so capable of inducing anger, fear, and sorrow. It's home is not a movie theater with the likes of "Scary Movie 4." The kind of movie that I can think of that produce emotion based on good writing would be your "Old Yeller" or "My Girl." These stories, while somewhat lame choices, are examples of writers and directors having the synergy to create an effective film.
According to Rotten Tomatoes, a film review and information web site, 93% of the reviewers gave United 93 a positive review. The coincidence is noted but unimportant. I'm frankly shocked to know that so many reviews would give this movie a positive review. Though a handful did make reference to Hollywood being "shameless" or distasteful it was not quite enough in my opinion. Some of the more trite and tired review quotes:
"we needed this movie" - Kevin Carr, 7M pictures
Fuck off. Don't speak for me. You know not what I need, nor the aching minds of many
others.
"Not since Bowling for Columbine has a movie left me so shaken up or so close to tears; that alone is a testament to Greengrass' achievement."-- Edward Douglas, COMINGSOON.NET
Effectively providing evidence for my point that real life trauma is an easier sell for
emotions. Though the point is that Greengrass' achievement has not a fucking thing to do
with Mr. Douglas being shaken.
A particularly stunning artifact is the overwhelming support of this movie by Republicans and war hawks. I don't get it. Shove your fucking "Never Forget." right up your square asshole. Please. I'm so tired of this. Look, there must be people in agreement with me on this. I hope. I know what I saw on September 11th and many days afterwards. I saw close to three thousand people die in a terrorist attack. I saw images of heroes everywhere. I saw people like myself, cowards maybe, willing to only give money to the red cross. I saw people jumping to their certain death from hundreds of feet in the air. Why do I need these things to be trivialized in a movie. I understand the movie is primarily about the one flight United 93. I also understand that that's bullshit and the other events on September 11th are not mutually exclusive. I can understand why other people might want to watch it, but I wish that option wasn't there.
By the by, Universal Pictures donating a measly 10 percent of the first three days gross is a fucking farce. To give it only to the United 93 folks is terribly suspect as well. There are times when I don't have any faith in people.
If you want to read the transcripts from the flight recorder they can be found here from the Smoking Gun.